Open Source Criminology Related Network Datasets

So I am a big proponent of open source data analysis. There is a problem with using criminal justice data sources though – they often have private information that prevents us from sharing the data. For example, I have posted quite a few of my projects here (mostly spatial data analysis), but there are a few I cannot share. For example, I worked on a paper with chronic offender predictions, and I cannot share that data (Wheeler et al., 2019). The outcome, being a victim or perpetrator of gun violence, is so rare that by itself basically makes it impossible to publicly share the data without exposing the individuals under study.

One good resource all criminologists should be aware of is ICPSR, in particular NACJD. Many datasets on there though anymore are restricted, in that you need to get IRB permission and ICPSR permision to download the dataset to use. (Which typically takes like 2~3 months in my experience doing it a few times, which includes both your local Uni IRB and the ICPSR process.) For example here is one I went through the motions to get to (in the end) validate different survival prediction methods.

ICPSR is a great resource to be able to handle sharing potentially sensitive data. But this falls short in two areas. One is in teaching – you cannot go through the IRB ritual in a timely enough fashion to be able to use those datasets in a course environment. The other is in terms of methods, so for example if you wanted to say your model provides better predictions than some other model, they should be established on the same datasets. Current state of affairs in criminology in this regard is pretty bad to be curt – most everybody uses their own data they have access to. So much of the research on different risk assessment instruments for bail/probation/parole are pretty much impossible to say one is better than another.

One example type of data source that is almost entirely missing from NACJD (that I am aware of) is social network datasets relevant for criminology/criminal justice. So I have started a spreadsheet to collate different open source network datasets relevant for criminologists. So I have some from my work and a few other random examples I have come across on the internet.

SPREADSHEET OF NETWORK DATASETS

I have made that spreadsheet open, so anyone should be able to edit in more sources. (Feel free to include links to ICPSR as well, but if you do edit a note to say whether it is restricted access or not.) For here I would be interested in really large networks, for example would love to try to replicate Marie’s work on gang network transitions (Oullet et al., 2019a).

And also while I am here, Jacob Young has created a very nice introductory course to social network analysis. I have a brief lecture in my advanced research design class, but Jacob’s is much more thorough (and he is more of an expert in this area than I am for sure).

I will add to that spreadsheet over time as well. I have made a separate sheet for survival analysis datasets. I would be particularly keen for example criminal justice examples. So for network analysis we have examples of looking at use-of-force networks (Oullet et al., 2019b), and for survival analysis I would be interested in a time to solve example dataset. Unfortunately for the solved cases, NIBRS is a good resource but has a large confound in they don’t measure whether a case was ever assigned to a detective.

Feel free to add whatever in that spreadsheet, but what I was thinking was oriented towards different methods (again as a main motivation is for teaching). So for example if you knew of datasets for age-period-cohort modelling, or for estimating group-based-trajectory models, I think those would be good examples to start new sheets and collate different data sources.

References

  • Ouellet, M., Bouchard, M., & Charette, Y. (2019a). One gang dies, another gains? The network dynamics of criminal group persistence. Criminology, 57(1), 5-33.
  • Ouellet, M., Hashimi, S., Gravel, J., & Papachristos, A. V. (2019b). Network exposure and excessive use of force: Investigating the social transmission of police misconduct. Criminology & Public Policy, 18(3), 675-704.
  • Wheeler, A. P., Worden, R. E., & Silver, J. R. (2019). The accuracy of the violent offender identification directive tool to predict future gun violence. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 46(5), 770-788.
Leave a comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: